On the last day of constitutional convention in Philadelphia, September 18, 1787, Elizabeth Willing Powell Asked Benjamin Franklin: “Well, doctor what have we got a republic or monarchy?”
He replied, “a constitutional republic if you can keep it”.
Given the fragile nature of the republic, Benjamin Franklin must have feared that it would not last long.
But never in his wildest dreams he would have imagined that it would not only not remain a constitutional republic but devolve into a banana republic presided over by a demagogue – a 34 times convicted felon and a serial liar - who would steal the sensitive classified information, store it in his bathroom at mar-a-lago and trample upon the constitution which he took the oath to uphold and, then, try to overthrow constitutional system of governance by inciting rebellion against the constitution by sending mob to the Capitol – the US congress, the seat of US government- just to keep himself in power after losing the 2020 election.
The same man now has turned the reins of the government over to world’s richest man - not elected by anyone and not accountable to anyone - who along with his henchmen is busily destroying the government by firing federal employees and cutting down programs that help Americans as well as the poorest population around the world.
Which brings fore the most pressing question – who is exactly in charge of the US government?
It seems USA has now two presidents – Donald John Trump and Elon Musk.
On
one hand, Elon Musk, who is dubbed as de-facto president or co-president, is
busy dismantling federal government through his illegitimate and
unconstitutional “Department of Government Efficiency – DOGE”.
From treasury to Health to NOAA, education etc., Elon Musk and his 18 to 25 year old henchmen who have no experience in government and whose backgrounds range from sketchy to racist, are giving marching orders to senior government employees.
FAA - Federal Aviation Administration is in turmoil as many air traffic controllers are fired just after a recent horrific crash at Washington D.C
Thousands of employees have been laid off from the Department of Health and Human services, all in the name of cutting waste and trimming the federal deficit. With bird-flu decimating chicken population – real reason for rise in egg prices, measles outbreak in Texas, and purging of the influenza information from CDC website on which health professionals rely, the country is one pandemic away from mass casualty health crisis.
Confirmation of Robert F. Kennedy Jr – a vaccine denier – brings no relief to the anxiety faced by the health professionals across the country and, by that extension, around the world.
The shenanigans of Musk’s henchmen have resulted in the closure of multiple programs designed to help poorest section of the American population, which resides mostly in red states.
It is quite ironic to find that the same population from red states believed the promises of the demagogue and voted to put him back in the oval office despite knowing the stunning failures of his first term including the heinous attack on the seat US Government power – the Capitol.
The Musk decimation or hollowing out of the federal government, has left many a people wondering – ranging from elected officials, legal scholars and academics – as to why such an unelected, unconfirmed and unaccountable person and his equally dodgy “DOGE” is allowed to take a wrecking ball to a constitutional system of 250 years.
On the other hand, Donald Trump – with an attention span of a gnat – is busy dismantling international alliances, trade treaties which he himself has signed (USMCA) and threatening allies.
Trump’s threats of invading Canada, Greenland or Panama, reeks of something that happened in not-too-distant past – Adolf Hitler’s concept of “lebensraum” – living space, occupying foreign land and exploiting their natural resources.
But the most crazy and ludicrous is his GAZAplan of relocating Palestinians from Gaza to Egypt and Jordan – which something Jordan would be extremely averse to do given their past painful experience with Palestinians - and turning the whole strip into a Riviera.
It is possible that he may have just spouted this nonsense to appear tough to his MAGA crowd, but the consequences would be terrible – rise in worldwide terrorism and USA possibly finding itself in the docks at The Hague on the charges of ethnic cleansing.
While Trump’s apologist and enablers dismiss many of his ramblings as mere jest, his words and actions have a profound impact.
His idea of imposing peace deal on Ukraine without participation of EU has set off alarm bells in Europe prompting French President Macron to schedule an emergency meeting in Paris. Germany and France are mulling deploying NATO troops to Greenland.
Threats against Canada has galvanized Canadian population in boycotting everything American – from travel to alcoholic beverages – and has sparked a panic in the US industries affected by the impromptu boycott that would result in job losses already exacerbating unemployment situation.
The fresh produce from Mexico also has begun to see price hike thereby straining the food budget of American citizens.
25% tariff on all steel and aluminum products is going the hit the auto sector adversely, prompting Ford CEO to issue warning of plant closures which means more unemployment.
But a lot of countries in the world, including adversaries, view the growing chaos in USA as “karmic justice which was long overdue”, as many of them have faced the same chaos caused by US interfering in their domestic political situation.
US hegemonic interventions have destabilized many countries in the world. Chaos in the USA, therefore, is seen as the USA getting a test of its own medicine.
The soft power that enabled the US to build alliances, was also used in a coercive manner in recent years by previous administrations - in the form of threats of sanctions and prosecutions – to browbeat countries into conforming to its own foreign policy goals, even if such coercion is to the detriment of the well-being of the country at the receiving end of such threats.
Just consider the example of India. Massive pressure was exerted on PM Modi’s government to not only join anti-Russia sanctions but to stop purchasing of cheap Russian oil even though such move would have caused great economic hardships to Indian population. For USA, that would have been just “collateral damage” - a necessary price that needs to be paid in order for USA to achieve its foreign policy goals.
There
are numerous examples of USA's meddling in the internal affairs of the India –
prime among them are protests against Farm Laws and anti-CAA protests (Citizen
Amendment Act – an act designed to benefit religious minorities from
Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan), financed through “soft power” of
“USAID”.
India’s
neighboring country, Bangladesh, has also faced such a wrath in the form of
violent overthrow of Sheikh Hasina government and its replacement by Mr. Yunus
– a radical, just for getting a military foothold in Bangladesh which the
Sheikh Hasina government was resisting. India resisted such pressure, but Bangladesh
could not, and the ugly results are there for all to see – a rise in religious
fundamentalism, atrocities on minorities, and ruin of once blooming textile
economy, etc.
Despite all the ugly warts and tendencies that it exhibits to maintain its dying hegemony, one must appreciate the fact that the USA is still a guiding light for freedom and a place to rebuild shattered personal lives - a trait not many countries in world exhibit, and, therefore, a much-needed pole in the fast-emerging multi-polar world to maintain global balance of power.
With Musk in charge of the federal government and the top guy Trump, not aware of anything but just content to play the pretend role of being president and the continued destruction of governance unleashed by them, the summer of 2025 looks to be very hot in political terms.
Mass purges of federal employees, DoJ staff in full revolt mode, Federal and district judges shutting down Trump’s unconstitutional executive orders, discontent flaring up against the rogue president and his co-president, and DOGE phase 3 about to begin, what the social conditions would look like by June, is anybody’s guess.
A mass demonstration against the rogue government, headed by Elon Musk, might descend into chaos and violence resulting in a Kent State massacre scenario.
That would simply provide Trump the pretext to impose martial law and suspend constitution and become a dictator as he so yearns to be.
Perhaps, this tweet of Trump is an indication of his thinking…
This is so eerily similar to Napoleonic quote “l'état, c'estmoi”, which in English means “I am the state”.
With so many judges issuing rulings to shut down trump administration’s unconstitutional agenda, folks like Vice-president J.D. Vance, Musk and many republicans advocating open defiance of the court orders, the country could be one such defiance of Supreme Court’s judgment, away from full blown constitutional crisis.
The coup then will be complete. The “Ruleof Law” will no longer be tenable. The descent into anarchy and dictatorship would begin.
The dark clouds of fascism are gathering on the horizon. USA now finds itself standing at the precipice.
Benjamin Franklin’s words “a constitutional republic, if you can keep it” now sound more ominous.